Interpersonal skills

What would you do in this situation?

You are a crew of a pirate ship. Last night right after dinner, a typhoon struck and your ship went through very rough seas. This morning, you and the other pirates reported to the Captain of the ship's condition.

There were minor damages which needed repairs but the ship can still sail; more importantly, your food and water supplies were contaminated, and could not be consumed.

The Captain then ordered you and the other crew to look for land to get fresh water and food. Your search produced the following islands.

You must now convince the Captain where he should steer the ship to.